Which camera?

Which camera to buy | insimoneskitchen.com

A lot of people ask me what kind of camera they should be buying to take good foodphotos. While that might sound like a simple question, it is not! Ofcourse I can all tell you to buy the most expensive digital SLR but I am sure that is not the answer you’re looking for.. 🙂 I am by no means an expert on the topic so I can only tell you my findings and opinion. Feel free to use it or not!

When writing this post I started out with explaining all the differences and then going into the technical details way too much; I mean if you’re not that into photography you might not know what aperture does or white balance so I was explaining it all, which lead to be a totally different post than the one I wanted to write! So starting all over; if you are looking for a new camera ask yourself first:

  • where are you going to use it for?
  • Do you mind carrying around heavy and clumsy cameras or are you more comfortable in having a pocketsized camera?
  • How technical do you want to get?
  • How serious are you about becoming a good photographer? Do you merely want to take nice photos for your blog or do you really want it to stand out from the average?
  • What is your budget? (a compact doesn’t necessarily have to be cheaper then an SLR, but keep in mind that you will need at least one lens to be able to operate the SLR)

There are many differences between an SLR and a compact camera but the main ones can be boiled down to the below list:

  1. An SLR has a larger sensor than a compact camera resulting in sharper and better quality images; again; if you only use photos at websize for your blog this might not make a huge difference to you.
  2. Possibility to change the aperture value and in general more options to change the settings on the camera. If you don’t want to do that stick to the compact. It would be a shame buying a SLR and then not using the possibilities. On the other hand; it will still give you superior quality results.
  3. With an SLR you can achieve a shallower DOF (depth of field) then with a compact. If you like the effect of a blurry background then that is easier to achieve with a SLR then with a compact. This is due to the size of the sensor and the general build of a compact. (You can see the difference between both type of camera’s in the below photo. Both taken with an aperture of 2.8. Dramatic difference in the visibility of the background!!)
SLR vs compact

SLR vs compact

3. Noiselevels; current day SLR’s are better capable of handling low light level and high iso then a compact camera. Part of this is due to the race for more pixels. Nowadays it seems that everyone beliefs that more pixels equals better photos, but that – sadly – is not necessarily true. Sure if I need to shoot something for a billboard then I would need to have as any pixels as I can get, but if I am only going to use my camera for everyday usage why would you need 12 megapixel cameras? On compact cameras an overdose of pixels also creates more noise, especially visible when you shoot on high iso. But even on low iso, the noiselevels in a compact will be higher then on a SLR. The example below is not entirely fair since I took the shot from my compact without a tripod so it is a little bit more blurry then the SLR one, but you get the general feel of the smoothness (and colorhandling!!) of a SLR vs compact.

macarons

The one taken with the SLR is bright and clear, colors are accurate and overall the image looks very smooth. The one taken with my compact on the other hand looks a bit drab in regards to color and you can see that it is more noisy then the other one. The compact one would probably benefit from a little exposure adjustment.

In the end it is still true that a good photo is taken by the photographer and not by the camera, but having good tools does help you achieve the best results. A compact camera will work very well when shooting in bright and clear conditions. When we go on holiday I use it all the time as I don’t want to carry around my heavy SLR and if the weather is good and I do not have to use flash the results are brilliant as you can see from the examples below.

However; in lower light conditions or indoors, the SLR beats the compact every time. That can be partially solved by getting good lights to light your indoors scene or moving the dish outdoors to take advantage of the light if it is not at night… 🙂

There are many more arguments for buying either a SLR or a compact, but without getting too technical these are the main differences in my opinion. It’s up to you to make the final call!

compact

Simone van den Berg

Food- and travelblogger from the Netherlands. Loves good food. Loves to taste good food the world over.
She also loves to share travelstories, delicious recipes and ok, cat pictures too. She sometimes feels the need to get really healthy for a while, always mingled with periods of insanely delicious sweets and other decadent treats.
Lives together with Tom and their two cats; Humphrey and Buffy.
Profession: Food photographer

27 comments

  1. Well said Simone! Are you enjoying your 5D Mk11? A lot of owners seem to be happy with it.

  2. Well said Simone! Are you enjoying your 5D Mk11? A lot of owners seem to be happy with it.

  3. Very interesting and helpful–thank you for taking the time to post such a thoughtful assessment!

  4. Very interesting and helpful–thank you for taking the time to post such a thoughtful assessment!

  5. WHAT??? It totally wipes out that background? OMG, that’s exactly what I need!!!
    Now a Cannon or Nikon? The one I have now is Cannon PowerShot.

  6. WHAT??? It totally wipes out that background? OMG, that’s exactly what I need!!!
    Now a Cannon or Nikon? The one I have now is Cannon PowerShot.

  7. Simone, this is a wonderful post–I love the comparisons. Will you do another post where you get more technical? I’m having fun with my new SLR, exploring all its potential.

  8. Simone, this is a wonderful post–I love the comparisons. Will you do another post where you get more technical? I’m having fun with my new SLR, exploring all its potential.

  9. thanks for this post!I’m thinking of buying an SLR

  10. thanks for this post!I’m thinking of buying an SLR

  11. Very nicely done comparison, Simone. Especially like that you bring out the functional differences without becoming very technical!

    btw, I use a point & shoot now and looking to go in for a SLR mainly because of the blur effect and the light effects 🙂

  12. Very nicely done comparison, Simone. Especially like that you bring out the functional differences without becoming very technical!

    btw, I use a point & shoot now and looking to go in for a SLR mainly because of the blur effect and the light effects 🙂

  13. I’ve been suffering with this question. I use a compact but keeping think I want an SLR though I didn’t really know why. Your comparison was really helpful. I still don’t now if I have the patience for an SLR (or desire to lug it around) but at least I understand the differences between the two. Thanks.

  14. Thanks Simone – after much debate I got the SLR – wish I had read this article before hand but it is still very useful!

  15. Great post. I just recently bought a Canon Digital SLR. I love the way the pictures come out. I’m still learning how to use all the functions but I think I’m getting better 🙂

  16. As someone who has an SLR as well as a point n shoot, but really has no idea as to what I am doing, and just want to take nice food pictures, I found this really helpful! Thanks so much for the post!

  17. Thanks so much for this very informative post! I have a Canon Powershot and have been pining for an SLR for quite some time. I know some other bloggers have recommended the Canon EOS Rebel. What are your thoughts on that one?

  18. Thanks so much for this very informative post! I have a Canon Powershot and have been pining for an SLR for quite some time. I know some other bloggers have recommended the Canon EOS Rebel. What are your thoughts on that one?

  19. A very informative post, Simone, thank you! Laurent and I have been discussing getting a new camera together, and he, who knows a lot more about photography than I do, also thinks an SLR would be a good choice. I’m especially interested in getting shallower DOF – it’s always such a drag having to be careful of hiding the mess in my apartment!

  20. A very informative post, Simone, thank you! Laurent and I have been discussing getting a new camera together, and he, who knows a lot more about photography than I do, also thinks an SLR would be a good choice. I’m especially interested in getting shallower DOF – it’s always such a drag having to be careful of hiding the mess in my apartment!

  21. I need two new cameras. I want to take great pictures. Thanks for the post.

  22. I need two new cameras. I want to take great pictures. Thanks for the post.

  23. I use a Nikon D70 and just love the camera….I need to upgrade, but am so in love with this “old” model that I am hesitant to change!!!

  24. Thanks for posting this! I was just given my first DSLR on Friday (a demo model Nikon D40 – a solid starter DSLR according to my much better than me so much so that he has sold some of his photography husband!) and even though I have not read the manual (!) I have already noticed a lot of difference, especially in depth of field. I am so excited to play!

  25. Thank you so much for your post on food photography. I’m quite lost and take miserable photos compared to the beautiful ones on ur site as well as FoodGawker etc. I always thought it was the photographer who has an ‘eye’ for light etc. takes a good photo, never did I realize how much the camera affects pics as well.

  26. Thanks so much for this post! I have been trying to get into food photography more, and really appreciate these tips. I have a Canon 60D and a Canon Rebel xs, I use the 60 D most (obviously). But my food and macro are still really lacking and I’m pretty sure it’s because of my lens choice… what is your favorite lens for food and macro? Thanks again!

    • He Payje, Glad you found the post helpful. My favorite lens – by far – for foodphotography is the 100mm 2.8 macro lens from Canon. It’s not a cheap lens but I use it for 90% of my foodphotography!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *